Sunday, January 28, 2007


The Wolves are Under Fire Once Again

A new ad being put out by the Wisconsin Cattlemen’s Association, Wisconsin’s six Safari Club International Chapters and houndsmen from the Wisconsin Bear Hunters’ is trying to portray the wolf as a vicious killer, but not just of animals, but also people.

"Little Red Riding Hood warned us about wolf,” the ad states, “and Little Red Riding Hood was right.” The ad goes on to cite DNR statistics showing that wolf attacks on livestock have tripled over the last three years. The ad concludes with a view of kids at a playground being closely watched by a wolf. Ahh propaganda at its finest.

What I find absurd is the Wisconsin Bear Hunters' contribution to the ad. I have no respect for them. They helped Wisconsin become one of the few states that allows both the usage of dogs and baiting to hunt bear. Former Minnesota Governor Jesse Ventura perhaps commented on this nature of hunting best when he said "Going out there and putting jelly doughnuts down, and Yogi comes up and sits there and thinks he's found the mother lode for five days in a row and then you back-shoot him from a tree?...That ain't sport that's an assassination." To make matters worse, if one of the hunters dogs are killed by a wolf, the hunters are reimbursed by the state. The extra fee on my endangered resources license plates help pay for that.

Still the ad trying to show the wolf as a serious threat to children is disturbing. The truth is, there have been no wolf attacks on people in Wisconsin, and there have been very few anywhere, unless the wolves were rabid or being fed. Ranchers and farmers lose much more livestock to weather, disease, and other predators than they do to the wolves. So why is the wolf being used as a scapegoat? Perhaps it's in our folklore.


Most of the European based stories and folklore seem to portray the wolf as the evil killer. We hear the stories of Little Red Ridinghood, the Three Little Pigs, Peter and the Wolf, and even in Norse mythology with Fenrir, the wolf offspring of Loki, who bit Odin's head off. Even the bible had Jesus protecting the sheep from the wolves implying the wolves as sinful or evil. Perhaps the worst was using wolves to signify the Nazis.

However, I have also found some cultures to view the wolf differently. The historic cultures that had more of a kinship between humans and animals seemed to respect the wolf. In Japanese folklore the wolf was often viewed as a messenger or even protector of the forest and mountains, guarding against fires and excessive cutting of trees. Native Americans had stories of the wolf as a great hunter. The eskimos admired the wolf for its survival skills. Even Romulus and Remus were kept alive by suckling on a she-wolf. Today it's the ecologists who cite the importance of the wolf for diversity and game animal control (we have too large of a deer population here in Northern Wisconsin).

For me, the wolf is a beautiful animal that has it's place in the environment. They were here before the ranchers or the hunters and cause less environmental destruction than cattle or sheep (or the hunters with their ATV's tearing through the woods). The wolf should be here to stay. I'll end my rant now.

Here are a couple links:

The Timber Wolf Alliance has a lot of info one the Wisconsin wolf packs.

Wolf Country has some interesting wolf stories and folklore. As does Wolf Song Alaska







Labels: ,

9 Comments:

At 6:53 PM, Blogger Toby said...

I'm all for the wolf for the simple reason, not simple to the wolves, they were here first. You spoke of too many deer, white tail, my friends in and around Barnes who have gardens but are not aloud to put up fences plant twice as much. Of course the ranchers can't raise twice as much cattle or sheep, but you make a valid point that wolves take little compared with all the other woes their stock suffers. The laws are aready loose regarding the wolf, not to mention the areas most complained about are so rual poaching of wolves is most likely way more prevalent then we know about. The few packs that are tracked lose a couple every year, lost into oblivion. The ones doing the tracking know where they met their demise, but without proof it's best to keep mouths shut or the poaching would only get worse. I'm glad to see Elk, wolves natural prey, not the white tail, reintroduced here a few years back, their herds are growing. There will alway be conflict, but maybe the Elk is a good comprimise... until those ranchers want to go shooting those TROPHY Elk.

 
At 11:23 PM, Blogger crallspace said...

Good post/ I've heard a lot about the wolf o'er in the northwest.

Idaho's regulations are "Not good enough" according to.. someone, I forget.

I can see the ranchers' concerns if the wolf is invading their area. At the same time, I believe wolves have a place in the environment.

Just as they serve as population control for the deer, etc., perhaps humans are coming up with ways to "control" their population.

 
At 12:20 AM, Blogger The Fool said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 12:22 AM, Blogger The Fool said...

Let me organize my thoughts before I enter this one. Wolves, their relation with other animal populations, and the aerial hunting of wolves, has been - and is - a huge debate up here. There is an extreme of representation on all sides of the issues, and determining a moderation is difficult. I'd also like to compare regional interpretations of the issue before blundering whole-heartedly. ;)

You both (H'lo Toby), provide a lot of information and different thoughts on the matter for a starting point. The only thing that I would like to add to the mix is that there is so much to learn about our own species by studying pack dynamics. So much. A few really good thinkers have gone after that one.

Wolves are magnificent creatures.

Thank you for the informative post. I'll return on this one.

 
At 12:31 AM, Blogger Carla said...

I call this kind of ad fear mongering. Why is it so tough to get a report of the true facts out? i.e. this many have been viciously attacked and killed by wolves in this state in the past year. I bet it was none. Funny you mention Romulus, Remus and the she wolf. I did a post on them on January 6th. We're trying to obliterate our wildlife and meanwhile Germany went up in arms when Bruno was shot...the first wild bear on German soil in 171 years.

 
At 5:48 AM, Blogger Mone said...

Carla - the shooting of Bruno is so shameful.

I like wolfes and I'm not afraid if I see one, because they are running away anyway. Another fact, what people tend to forget is, that mankinds best friend, the dog originally comes from a wolf.

 
At 12:52 PM, Blogger BurdockBoy said...

Toby: 9 wolves were shot and killed by hunters this year in Wisco during the hunting season. Accidents? I doubt it.
I hope the elk will prosper more than they have been as of recently in the Clam Lake area. It is exciting. Also I was fortunate to see the Bayfield area pack several times when I lived in Cornucopia.

Crall: I can feel for the ranchers to a certain point as well, but there needs to be a limit. They are compesated for their loses and I have even heard of ranchers abusing the system by blaming wolves when their animals met some other fate. Oh, and what ways do you think humans are coming up to control our population?

Fool: the pack dynamics of wolves are fascinating, but I must admit ignorance on the subject. I would like to learn more from Northland College, they have done a lot of studies on the packs up here. I look forward to hearing from you on the wolf debate in Alaska.

Fear mongering indeed. You mentioned our reactions to the killing of wildlife. It often depends on the animal and the side of the debate one is on. There was an albino deer not too far from where I live that many people admired. Then one season a hunter from Minnesota shot it and people just freaked out. It was a similar reaction to the Bruno story.

Mone: Coyotes even have a worse reputation and they are also related to dogs. The people mostly opposed to wolves and coyotes are the people who have an invested interes in their removal. They don't think in terms of historical ancestory or biological diversity.

 
At 5:59 PM, Blogger Toby said...

I've only seen wolves around hayward once, it was back in the early 80's. We heard them howling from far away and from near. It was dark out, but after a few minutes of the howling going back and forth the wolves that were near, about three or four, ran across the dirt road heading in the direction of the ones from afar.

 
At 6:02 PM, Blogger Toby said...

Oh yeah, accidents? What a joke. Remember the woman who shot the Moose about 10 years ago somewhere near Laona (sp?). She said she thought it was a white tail. Another classic accident.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home